Sometime I like almost all the panels in a game, but still it doesn't make it to my favorites.
Does it happen to you, or do you mark a game as a fave in such a case?
I'm very generous with faves, but I think I'm an outlier in that. There are a few games where I've upvoted everything and not faved the game, but those are pretty rare. A little more common would be those where I've upvoted everything besides something noxious and trolltastic, and my reason for not faving the game as a whole had to do with not wanting to reward the trolling. In some cases, though, the non-troll panels were so great I didn't want to unjustly not fave it for that reason. (That's a clotted sentence I ought to rewrite, but I'm running short on time, so I'll post this as is.)
Yeah, it happens to me, too. These days, since I don't play much anymore, I just check new games to thumb up panels which I feel are deserving. Sometimes, I end up liking all panels in one game. Still, it doesn't necessarily mean it's a favorite. (It's rare if I I thumb up all and not favorite their game, though!)
I don't have any one criteria that makes me favorite a game. If anything, it depends on why I'd want to keep in my list. For instance, do I want to check back on the game? Would I like to link it to someone in the future? Does it flow well overall? Is it a game that would make me laugh again despite how many times I see it?
(Also, sometimes I favorite it because I want to help bump it to a top game in hopes that others see it. I feel that this method is a little broken, though.)
Please login to post a reply.